I like the formula. It's densely pigmented and a lovely rich color. However I have two of them, and neither will stay in their tubes unless absolutely upright. Otherwise it's always stuck to the lid. Makes me always want to reach for something else.

Thanks to Wild Carrot’s customer care team, after reading my previous negative review, they offered to send me a new tube due to possibly having received a bad batch in my original purchase. They were right! The replacement tube they sent is excellent. It glides on. No mess. Beautiful color. The first one I received was sticky and hard and just couldn’t be used after maybe the first or second application. The new one is great, and I’d definitely recommend. Nice “healthy glow” color for women who like a naturally flushed look. Going to order a lighter color to blend for different seasons (and different skin tone when I’ve been in the sun). Go for it!

Two stars are for the pretty color. I do love that part! Unfortunately, this stuff is so hard and sticky that after the first week, it hardened up in the tube and I literally cannot apply it. I tried using a brush but that got very sticky and gummed up, so I went to fingers , but then you have to dig it out and it gets everywhere. It’s a good idea, but not good execution. Unusual for this company, so don’t let this deter you from their other amazing products!

Sorry to report that this is the first Wild Carrot product I've met that really was not good. This tinted balm is sticky, doesn't smell nice, and is not a reddish / purple color like you would expect from beets, but more orange upon application. I guess the only good thing I can say is that the color really lasts. If you apply it with your fingers, it gets *everywhere* and doesn't come out easily.
I do appreciate the plastic-free packaging!

I really love the Among the Flowers lip and cheek tint! Long lasting, great color that adds natural glow to my cheeks and good color to my lips. Already planning on buying more this weekend!